Aggregation Metrics: Consumer Attitudes towards Online Aggregation and Broking of Financial Services in Italy

Published by: Finaccord Ltd.

Published: Sep. 1, 2008 - 80 Pages


Table of Contents

0.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Two-thirds of consumers in Italy have bought travel tickets and/or books or music online…

… compared to one-third who have bought insurance online

Women are significantly less likely to research and/or buy financial services online than men

For both banking and insurance, two-thirds of online consumers use three to five websites

Internet sales are experiencing rapid growth

Direct lenders and insurers have lost share of sales in all four product areas…

… but direct insurers are performing much better online than offline

Switching insurer is far more common for motor insurance than for household insurance

Consumers struggle to recognise websites not belonging to direct lenders and insurers

Consumers understand the role of brokers but are not familiar with aggregators

1.0 INTRODUCTION

Finaccord

European consumer research

Aggregation

European market, partnership and bancassurance research

Research rationale

Online aggregation is having a major impact on financial services distribution

Interest in online aggregation is not limited to traditional providers of consumer financial services

The growth and influence of Confused.com and Moneysupermarket.com are beyond dispute…

… although the UK now endures a surplus of competitors in online aggregation and broking

Heavy spending on advertising has helped the industry leaders to stay ahead of the pack

The Aggregation Metrics research has been structured to test the appetite of consumers in Europe .... 10

2.0 SURVEY ANALYSIS

Introduction

Consumer propensity to purchase via the Internet

Two thirds of consumers in Italy have bought travel tickets and/or books or music online…

…while one third have taken out insurance via the Internet

Overlap between people who buy financial services online with telecoms and computing customers ... 17

Propensity to research and take out financial products over the Internet

Banking products

Six consumers out of ten use the Internet to research and / or take out banking products

Use of the Internet to buy financial services online varies sharply between men and women

Insurance products

Use of the Internet to research insurance products is slightly less than for banking

Online behaviour for researching and acquiring insurance varies among consumer groups

Comparison with European average

Number of websites visited prior to taking out financial products online

Banking products

Online customers are most likely to solicit details for banking products on three occasions…

Insurance products

… with a similar pattern of behaviour for insurance

Mortgages

Switching rates and brand new loans

Analysis of distribution interfaces used

A rapid shift away from face-to-face distribution to remote interfaces, especially the Internet…

Analysis of distribution channels used

… has helped mortgage brokers and estate agents ito increase their share of sales

Personal loans

Switching rates and brand new loans

Analysis of distribution interfaces used

Internet sales have risen at the expense of face-to-face and telephone sales

Analysis of distribution channels used

… with loan brokers having been squeezed by credit brokers and supermarkets / other retailers

Comparison of distribution channels used by offline and online customers

Growth of Internet distribution has contributed heavily to a decline in direct lending by banks

Motor insurance

Switching rates and brand new sales

Analysis of distribution interfaces used

A third of motor insurance sales are now made online

Analysis of distribution channels used

Brokers and banks have increased their share of motor insurance sales…

Comparison of distribution channels used by offline and online customers

… but direct insurers are thriving on the Internet

Household insurance

Switching rates and brand new sales

Analysis of distribution interfaces used

Internet sales are on the same upward trend for household insurance as for motor insurance…

Analysis of distribution channels used

…banks are now as important as insurance agents for household insurance

Summary of market attractiveness for online aggregators and brokers

Banking appears to offer better prospects for online aggregators and brokers than insurance

Switching increases the market available for aggregators and brokers

Switchers easily outnumber new customers for motor insurance, but only just for household cover

Online aggregators and brokers of financial services

Recognition rates

Few online aggregators or brokers achieve consumer recognition rates in excess of 20%

Consumer understanding of aggregation and broking concepts

Brokers of financial services

Most consumers are aware of the difference between brokers and direct lenders and insurers…

Aggregators of financial services

… but show much less awareness of the difference between aggregators and brokers

3.0 APPENDIX

Research sample

The research embraces a total of 1,006 respondents in Italy

Research questionnaire

GRAPHICS / TABLES

Consumer propensity to purchase assorted goods and services via the Internet in Italy, 2008

Comparison of consumer propensity to purchase assorted goods and services via the Internet in Italy, 2008 (data)

Consumer propensity to purchase assorted goods and services via the Internet in Italy, all respondents and financial services online customers, 2008

Consumer propensity to research and take out banking products over the Internet in Italy, 2008

Consumer propensity to research and take out banking products over the Internet in Italy, 2008: segmentation by gender, age group, household income and longevity of Internet usage (data)

Consumer propensity to research and take out insurance products over the Internet in Italy, 2008

Consumer propensity to research and take out insurance products over the Internet in Italy, 2008: segmentation by gender, age group, household income and longevity of Internet usage (data)

Use of the Internet to research and buy financial services in Italy and Europe, 2008

Number of websites visited by consumers in Italy prior to taking out banking products over the Internet, 2008

Number of websites visited by consumers in Italy prior to taking out insurance over the Internet, 2008


% of consumers in Italy switching provider or acquiring mortgages for the first time, H2 2007 / H1 2008

Analysis of distribution interfaces used by consumers in Italy for acquiring mortgages, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods

Analysis of distribution interfaces used by consumers in Italy for acquiring mortgages, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods (data)

Analysis of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring mortgages, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods

Analysis of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring mortgages, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods (data)

% of consumers in Italy switching provider or acquiring personal loans for the first time, H2 2007 / H1 2008

Analysis of distribution interfaces used by consumers in Italy for acquiring personal loans, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods

Analysis of distribution interfaces used by consumers in Italy for acquiring personal loans, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods (data)

Analysis of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring personal loans, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods

Analysis of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring personal loans, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods (data)

Comparison of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring personal loans offline and online, H2 2007 / H1 2008

Comparison of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring personal loans offline and online, H2 2007 / H1 2008 (data)

% of consumers in Italy switching provider or acquiring motor insurance for the first time, H2 2007 / H1 2008

Analysis of distribution interfaces used by consumers in Italy for acquiring motor insurance, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods

Analysis of distribution interfaces used by consumers in Italy for acquiring motor insurance, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods (data)

Analysis of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring motor insurance, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods

Analysis of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring motor insurance, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods (data)

Comparison of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring motor insurance offline and online, H2 2007 / H1 2008

Comparison of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring motor insurance offline and online, H2 2007 / H1 2008 (data)

% of consumers in Italy switching provider or acquiring household insurance for the first time, H2 2007 / H1 2008

Analysis of distribution interfaces used by consumers in Italy for acquiring household insurance, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods

Analysis of distribution interfaces used by consumers in Italy for acquiring household insurance, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods (data)

Analysis of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring household insurance, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods

Analysis of distribution channels used by consumers in Italy for acquiring household insurance, H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods (data)

Attractiveness of markets for online aggregators and brokers in Italy: sales in H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods

Attractiveness of markets for online aggregators and brokers in Italy: sales in H2 2007 / H1 2008 and all previous periods (data)

Comparison of churn rates and new customers for selected financial services in Italy, H2 2007 / H1 2008 (data)

Consumer recognition rates for online aggregators, brokers and other providers of Internet financial services in Italy, 2008

Consumer recognition rates for online aggregators, brokers and other providers of Internet financial services in Italy, 2008 (data)

Consumer understanding in Italy of the difference between brokers of financial services and the financial institutions themselves, 2008

Consumer understanding in Italy of the difference between aggregators of financial services and brokers of financial services, 2008

Sample breakdown in Italy by age group and household income band

Sample breakdown in Italy by geographical location

Abstract

Finaccord’s report titled Aggregation Metrics: Consumer Attitudes towards Online Aggregation and Broking of Financial Services in Italy offers detailed and unique insights into the behaviour of Italian consumers in the context of financial services distribution with a particular focus on the prospects for online aggregation and broking. Based on a primary survey of over 1,000 consumers in Italy carried out between July and August 2008, the research provides robust and valuable data describing the way in which consumers’ use of distribution interfaces and channels is changing when they acquire financial services. In addition to investigating the extent to which consumers in Italy acquire banking or insurance products via the Internet at all, the research also analyses the degree to which they compare product prices and characteristics prior to buying and the number of websites they typically visit for this purpose. Moreover, for each of mortgages, personal loans, motor insurance and household insurance, it provides annual churn data and detailed distribution interface and channel analyses to illustrate the future potential of both on-line aggregation and broking, and alternative distribution systems. Furthermore, the report measures the consumer recognition rates achieved by leading online aggregators and brokers in Italy, and how these compare to the online brands of major direct providers, and also considers the extent to which consumers in Italy are aware of and / or value the fundamental concepts of online aggregation and broking. Key features of the report include: insight into the propensity of Italian consumers to buy goods and services online, including segmentation of customers for online financial services; analysis of how consumers in Italy use the Internet for financial services including how they use it for research as well as for buying online, how many websites they visit before taking out banking or insurance products, and whether their choice of website is influenced by its status as the online shop window of a bank or insurance company (ie. the ultimate provider), an aggregator or a broker; brand recognition of 20 financial websites in Italy including those of the leading direct providers of banking and insurance products as well as those of the most prominent aggregators and / or brokers; benchmarks for the distribution of four key products in Italy (mortgages, personal loans, motor insurance and household insurance), measuring the segmentation of sales by distribution channel and by interface, and how this is changing over time; overall summary of the apparent attractiveness of markets for online aggregation and broking, comparing sales by brokers against sales via the Internet and their rates of change in Italy.

Get full details about this report >>
 
Learn more about this product


Price and delivery options

Search Inside Report

US: 800.298.5699

Int'l: +1.240.747.3093


 

About MarketResearch.com
MarketResearch.com is an online aggregator selling over 400,000 market research reports, company profiles and country profiles from over 720 research firms. Our reports will provide you with the critical business and competitive intelligence you need for strategic planning and marketing research. Coverage includes the US, UK, Europe, Asia and global markets.