UK Commercial Motor Insurance 2009

Published by: Datamonitor

Published: Aug. 18, 2009

Table of Contents

Overview

Catalyst

Summary

Executive Summary

The commercial motor insurance market is under pressure from the recession and claims inflation

The recession is likely to have a depressing impact on commercial motor insurance GWP

Bodily injury claims are typically more expensive than the average claim

The market continued to contract in size in 2008 as GWP declined in both market segments

The market is estimated to have contracted by approximately 3.1% in 2008

Average premium rates across both fleet and commercial vehicle have declined

Fleet policies decreased while other commercial motor insurance vehicle years increased in 2008

Large national brokers continue to dominate commercial motor insurance distribution

Commercial motor insurance distribution is considered to be most at risk from the direct channel

Brokers remained the dominant distribution channel targeting SMEs in 2008

Only 40.9% of SMEs would buy their motor insurance over the telephone or internet

RSA and Aviva remained the leading commercial motor insurers in 2008

Aviva retained its position as the market leader in 2008

Zurich recorded a large increase in market share in 2008

Allianz, RSA and Zurich beat the market average COR

Allianz, Tradex, Aviva Zurich, RSA, and NFU recorded reported year CORs below 100% in 2008

The commercial motor market is forecast to reach £3.7 billion by 2013 as premium rates rise

The UK commercial motor insurance market is forecast to reach a value of £3.7 billion in 2013

The commercial motor insurance market is forecast to improve its underwriting performance throughout the forecast period

Market Issues

Introduction

The acquisition of Westminster by Tradex has created a new top 10 player

The new combined commercial motor insurer is a black cab market powerhouse

Tradex is adept at using multiple channels to deliver its specialist commercial motor insurance policies

Westminster was a specialist in the competitive London taxi market

The recession is likely to have a depressing impact on commercial motor insurance GWP

Lower turnover and GDP will mean that few companies will be looking to expand their motor fleets

Insurers exposed to the motor trade are likely to suffer, as this sector faces falling sales

More company insolvencies will mean premium growth will not be generated by increases in volume

An increase in crime brought on by unemployment could increase claims costs for motor insurers

The commercial motor parc is likely to experience slower growth due to the recession

High claims costs and inflation have been reducing commercial motor insurers' margins

Bodily injury claims are typically more expensive than the average claim

Legal costs inflation has been identified as a key driver of claims inflation, particularly for smaller personal injury motor claims

Medical inflation is a major driver for larger personal injury claims costs

Insurers need to speed up the claims settlement process to eliminate unnecessary bills from credit hire companies on third-party non-fault claimants

An increase in uninsured driving and fraudulent claims is placing increasing pressure on UK insurers

Market Context

Introduction

The market continued to contract in size in 2008 as GWP declined in both market segments

The market is still highly competitive and experiencing soft premium rates

The market is estimated to have contracted by approximately 3.1% in 2008

Lloyd's market insurers have a significant presence in the UK motor market

Fleet insurance policies account for the bulk of the GWP in the commercial motor insurance market

Policies in force and premium rates have led to a contraction in GWP in the market

Average premium rates across both fleet and commercial vehicle have declined

There were a total of 4.4 million commercial motor policies in force in 2008

Fleet policies decreased while other commercial motor insurance vehicle years increased in 2008

The commercial motor parc grew by 2.7% in 2008

The total number of vehicles in the commercial motor parc continued to grow in 2008

There has been only a marginal shift in segmentation as the proportion of other vehicles increased

The company car parc remained broadly stable as a proportion of both the total car parc and overall vehicles

Claims costs continue to increase keeping pressure on margins

Gross claims costs for commercial motor insurers were estimated to have increased by 2.7% in 2008

Claims inflation continues to plague the market due to escalating bodily injury claims and credit hire costs

Claims frequency deteriorated in 2008, although the overall trend in recent years has been positive

Insurers are benefiting from improving accident rates

Falling road traffic accident rates mean fewer opportunities for expensive personal injury claims to arise

Road traffic accident numbers fell in 2008, continuing a trend from previous years

Road traffic accidents declined even as car numbers increased, signifying a fall in frequency

Casualty rates have fallen steadily, mirroring the continuous decline in road traffic accidents

The combined ratio for the commercial motor market peaked in 2007 but has started to improve

Commercial motor insurance losses improved in 2008

The total motor insurance and commercial motor insurance COR should continue reducing in the coming years

The industry made substantial reserve releases in 2008

Distribution Dynamics

Introduction

Large national brokers continue to dominate commercial insurance distribution

Independent insurance intermediaries of all types retain their leading market share in 2008

Direct players account for a small but growing portion of the commercial general insurance market

Corporate partnerships have maintained only a small presence in the commercial insurance market

Banks and building societies distribute negligible amounts of commercial general insurance

Commercial motor insurance distribution is considered to be most at risk from the direct channel

The broker channel continues to dominate the SME market with retention levels high

Brokers remained the dominant distribution channel targeting SMEs in 2008

The internet is the least common platform for SMEs purchasing commercial insurance

The majority of SMEs remain satisfied with their insurance provider

Long-standing relationships are important to SMEs purchasing commercial insurance

SMEs purchasing their insurance through a bank or a broker value advice from their insurance providers the most

Price is important to many SMEs choosing an insurance provider

A significant proportion of SMEs are open to purchasing their insurance via the internet or phone

The convenience factor of the phone is appealing to many SMEs considering a telephone purchase

Many SMEs are unwilling to purchase their insurance over the telephone

Over a third of SMEs would consider a purchase online

Only 40.9% of SMEs would buy their motor insurance over the telephone or internet

Competitor Focus

Introduction

RSA and Aviva remained the leading commercial motor insurers in 2008

Aviva retained its position as the market leader in 2008

RSA's market share increased by 0.5 percentage points

Zurich, Allianz, NFU, AXA and QBE gained market share in 2008

Zurich recorded a large increase in market share in 2008

Allianz's market share grew in 2008

NFU Mutual grew its market share by 0.4 percentage points in 2008 and achieved growth of 3.3% in GWP

AXA continued to grow, increasing its market share by 0.2 percentage points in 2008

RBS' market share remained at 4.1% in 2008

QBE achieved growth and possesses the largest commercial vehicle book among the top 10 commercial motor insurers

Two insurers, Tradex and Liverpool Victoria, gained market share through acquisitions in 2008

Liverpool Victoria Group gained a significant presence in the commercial motor market after its acquisition of Highway in 2008

Tradex's commercial motor insurance book experienced significant gains in 2008 due to organic and inorganic growth

Mid-sized commercial motor insurers gained 2.0 percentage points of market share in 2008

Brit, Groupama, HSBC and Fortis all increased their exposure to the commercial motor insurance market in 2008

Brit Insurance recorded the largest growth in GWP among the top 20 commercial motor insurers

Groupama grew its market share by 0.3 percentage points and achieved growth of 20.0% in GWP

HSBC increased the amount of its commercial motor insurance book that it underwrote in 2008

Fortis recoded the largest growth in GWP among the top 20 commercial motor insurers in 2008

Travelers, commercial motor book increased by 12.29% in 2008

AIG, CIS and FIM Holding's market shares were reduced in 2008

AIG's commercial market share declined by 0.5 percentage points

CIS's market share in commercial motor declined by 0.3 percentage points in 2008

FIM Holdings declined by 16.8% resulting in a lower commercial motor market share

MMA and Allchurches had relatively stable market shares in 2008

All of the top 10 commercial motor insurance groups have mixed motor insurance portfolios

Most of the top 10 commercial motor insurers' books were dominated by fleet business in 2008

Allianz, RSA and Zurich recorded accident year CORs much lower than the market average

All of the leading commercial motor insurance groups had an unprofitable year on an accident year basis

Allianz, RSA and Zurich beat the market average COR

Allianz, Tradex, Aviva, Zurich, RSA and NFU Mutual achieved an underwriting profit on a reported year basis

The top 10 commercial motor insurers have relied on reserve releases in recent years to lower their CORs

Allianz, Tradex, Aviva Zurich, RSA, and NFU recorded reported year CORs below 100% in 2008

Future Decoded

Introduction

The commercial motor market is forecast to reach £3.7 billion by 2013 as premium rates rise

Premium rate increases will be the primary factor driving growth in the commercial motor insurance market

The UK commercial motor insurance market is forecast to reach a value of £3.7 billion in 2013

The fleet motor insurance market will be worth £3.1 billion in 2013

The commercial motor insurance market is forecast to improve its underwriting performance throughout the forecast period

APPENDIX

Definitions

ABI members

Accident year combined ratio

Bancassurers

Brokers

Brandassurers

Channel

Direct insurer/writer

Earned premiums

Gross premium

Net premium

Platform

Reported year combined ratio

Reserve development

Written premiums

Methodology

Datamonitor's Commercial Broker Survey H1 2009

Datamonitor's SME Insurance Survey Q1 2008

Further reading

Ask the analyst

Datamonitor consulting

Disclaimer

List of Tables

Table 1: New car registrations in the UK, 2000-09f

Table 2: UK company liquidations, 2003-08p

Table 3: Commercial motor theft claims cost and number

Table 4: UK unemployment, Q4 2004 to Q4 2008

Table 5: New commercial vehicle registrations in Great Britain by body type, 2004-08 (000s)

Table 6: UK average cost of bodily injury claims notified two years previously, 2003-07 (£)

Table 7: Change in average premium rates and total commercial motor market size, 1996-2008e*

Table 8: UK motor insurance NWP split between ABI members and Lloyd's, 2007 (£m)

Table 9: Commercial motor GWP by line of business, 2005-08e (£m)

Table 10: Fleet and commercial vehicle average per vehicle premium rate changes, 2005-08e

Table 11: Motor policies in force, 1998-2008 (000s)

Table 12: Commercial motor parc in Great Britain by body type, 2004-08 (000s)

Table 13: Commercial motor parc in Great Britain by body type, 2007-08

Table 14: Company car parc's share of total car parc, 2004-08 (000s)

Table 15: Commercial motor gross claims costs, 2002-08e (£000)

Table 16: Average motor claim costs, 2003-07 (£)

Table 17: Commercial motor claims volume and frequency, 1998-2008

Table 18: Total number of road accidents in the UK, 1998-2008* (000s)

Table 19: Road traffic accidents relative to registered vehicles in Great Britain, 1998-2008 (000s)

Table 20: Deaths, seriously and slightly injured casualties resulting from UK road traffic accidents, 2004-08*

Table 21: Accident and reported year COR, commercial motor market, 2005-08 (%)

Table 22: Market share of distribution channels in the commercial general insurance market, 2004-08e

Table 23: Q: ""How important is it to receive advice on an ongoing basis from your insurance provider?""

Table 24: Gross written premium and market share of the top 10 UK commercial motor insurance groups, 2007-08

Table 25: Gross written premium and market share of the top 11-20 UK commercial motor insurance groups, 2007-08

Table 26: Top 10 commercial motor insurers' fleet and commercial vehicle books, 2007-08

Table 27: Accident year combined ratio and underwriting profit/loss for commercial motor business, top 10 motor insurance groups, 2008

Table 28: Reported year combined ratio and underwriting profit/loss for commercial motor business, top 10 commercial motor insurance groups, 2008

Table 29: Key variables affecting commercial motor insurance GWP, 2008e-13f

Table 30: UK commercial motor insurance GWP forecast, 1996-2013f (£m)

Table 31: Commercial motor GWP by line of business, 2005-13f (£m)

Table 32: Commercial motor accident year profitability ratio, 2005-2013f (%)

Table 33: Q: ""What business sector are you involved in?""

Table 34: Q: ""How large is your company in terms of number of employees?""

Table 35: Q: ""How large is your company in terms of turnover?""

List of Figures

Figure 1: The 2007 average UK motor claim cost for bodily injury was notably higher than in previous years

Figure 2: SMEs are equally likely to buy motor cover over the internet or telephone

Figure 3: The combined commercial motor insurance books of Tradex and Westminster gave them a market share of 2.7%

Figure 4: The British economy has been contracting since mid-2008

Figure 5: UK company liquidations have already begun increasing

Figure 6: New commercial vehicle registrations slowed in 2008 and are expected to contract further in 2009

Figure 7: The 2007 average UK motor claim cost for bodily injury was notably higher than in previous years

Figure 8: The commercial motor insurance market continued to contract due to lower premium rates

Figure 9: Lloyd's syndicates underwrote £1 billion of motor insurance business in 2007

Figure 10: Premium income from both commercial motor lines was expected to have contracted in 2008

Figure 11: Premium rate growth in the commercial motor insurance market remained negative in 2008

Figure 12: Fleet policies make up the majority of the commercial motor market

Figure 13: The share of policies for commercial vehicles is much reduced from even five years ago

Figure 14: Commercial motor vehicles continued to increase in 2008 although at a lower rate

Figure 15: Light goods vehicles and company cars account for most of the commercial motor parc

Figure 16: The company car parc remained broadly stable while the total car parc grew gradually

Figure 17: The average motor claim cost continued to rise rapidly in 2007 at 14.1%

Figure 18: Commercial motor claims volume and frequency increased in 2008

Figure 19: The number of UK road accidents has continued to fall since 1998

Figure 20: Accidents in the UK have fallen despite a steady increase in the number of vehicles

Figure 21: Casualties continued to decline across all categories in 2008

Figure 22: The commercial motor insurance accident year COR appears to be recovering

Figure 23: The combined ratio for commercial motor has begun to improve

Figure 24: Commercial motor insurers continued to make reserve releases in 2008 to improve their reported year COR

Figure 25: Brokers are the dominant route to market for commercial insurers in the UK

Figure 26: Commercial motor is considered to be at most risk from the direct channel

Figure 27: Most SMEs purchase their commercial insurance through the broker channel

Figure 28: Most SMEs purchase their insurance through face-to-face contact with their insurance provider

Figure 29: Most SMEs are satisfied with the service they have received from their insurance providers

Figure 30: A large proportion of SMEs have been with their insurance provider for more than 10 years

Figure 31: Receiving ongoing advice from their insurance provider is important to most SMEs

Figure 32: Many SMEs consider the price of an insurance premium to be the most important factor when choosing a commercial insurance provider

Figure 33: The convenience factor appeals to many SMEs prepared to purchase insurance over the phone

Figure 34: A significant proportion of SMEs would not consider a telephone purchase because they simply prefer face-to-face

Figure 35: A significant proportion of SMEs who would consider a purchase online think price is an important factor

Figure 36: SMEs show only a moderate inclination to purchase motor insurance via the telephone or internet

Figure 37: Most top 10 commercial insurers gained market share in 2008

Figure 38: Most of the 11-20 commercial motor insurers gained market share in 2008

Figure 39: Most of the top 10 commercial motor insurers underwrite primarily in the fleet market

Figure 40: Allianz, RSA and Zurich recorded CORs that were lower than the market average

Figure 41: Allianz, Tradex, Aviva, Zurich, RSA and NFU Mutual recorded CORs below 100% in 2008 after reserve releases

Figure 42: Growth in premium income is forecast to turn around in 2009

Figure 43: The market will continue to be based primarily on fleet policy income and will turn to growth

Figure 44: Underwriting losses are forecast to decline

Abstract

Introduction

The report is an invaluable guide to the UK commercial motor insurance market, providing insight into competitor strategies, profitability and performance as well as overall market growth and trends. It examines trends in distribution and identifies the key drivers behind claims inflation. The report also provides forecasts for the size and profitability of the market up to 2013.

Scope

• Obtain the latest market size and profitability analysis of the UK commercial motor insurance market
• Insight into the effects of the recession on the market, including the major changes to the competitor rankings
• Detailed market growth and profitability forecasts based on Datamonitor's in-house model and expertise

• When SMEs were asked which commercial products they were most likely to buy using the telephone and internet platforms, employers' liability and public liability were the two most commonly cited answers, whereas only 40.9% of SMEs would do so with their commercial motor insurance.
• All of the insurers in the top 10 had at least some exposure to the commercial vehicle market in 2008, although fleet business dominates the books of the majority of these insurers. This is unsurprising given that the fleet market is much larger than that for commercial vehicle cover, allowing insurers to develop substantial books of business.

• Analysis of the performance of the key sectors of the UK commercial motor insurance market
• Benchmark your company against your competitors based on market share data and profitability ratios
• Develop your future business plans from an informed viewpoint with Datamonitor's market forecast

About MarketResearch.com
MarketResearch.com is an online aggregator selling over 250,000 market research reports, company profiles and country profiles from over 650 research firms. Our reports will provide you with the critical business and competitive intelligence you need for strategic planning and marketing research. Coverage includes the US, UK, Europe, Asia and global markets.